Herman Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” is a quintessential American short story that explores themes of isolation, despair, individuality, and the dehumanizing effects of modern capitalism. Published in 1853, the narrative remains a powerful reflection on the human condition, societal expectations, and the complexities of empathy. At its core, the story presents the enigmatic character of Bartleby, whose passive resistance and mysterious demeanor challenge conventional notions of productivity and morality. This article delves into the story’s plot, characters, themes, and its enduring significance in American literature.
---
Overview of "Bartleby, the Scrivener"
Summary of the Plot
“Bartleby, the Scrivener” is narrated by an unnamed lawyer who runs a small law office on Wall Street. The lawyer employs three scriveners — Turkey, Nippers, and Bartleby — each with their own quirks and flaws. Initially, Bartleby is introduced as a diligent and meticulous worker, but his behavior begins to shift when he responds to the lawyer’s request with the famous phrase, “I would prefer not to.” Over time, Bartleby’s passive refusal to perform tasks escalates, ultimately leading to his eviction and subsequent death in prison.
The story unfolds through the lawyer’s observations and reflections, revealing the complex relationship between employer and employee, and raising questions about morality, duty, and the limits of compassion. The lawyer’s attempts to understand and help Bartleby are ultimately thwarted by the latter’s obstinate refusal to conform.
Major Characters
- The Narrator (The Lawyer): A compassionate yet pragmatic man who owns the law office and serves as the story’s moral center.
- Bartleby: The enigmatic scrivener whose passive resistance and mysterious background symbolize deeper societal issues.
- Turkey: An aging scrivener prone to emotional outbursts and overwork.
- Nippers: A young, irritable scrivener with a nervous disposition.
- Ginger Nut: A young boy employed to run errands, serving as a minor but symbolic character.
---
Thematic Analysis of "Bartleby, the Scrivener"
1. The Dehumanizing Effects of Capitalism
Melville’s story critically examines the ways in which the burgeoning capitalist society dehumanizes individuals. The scriveners are portrayed as cogs in a machine, their identities reduced to mere functions within the office. Bartleby’s refusal to conform underscores the personal toll of this mechanization, highlighting how the relentless pursuit of productivity can strip individuals of their humanity.
Key points:
- The office environment is sterile and impersonal.
- The scriveners’ roles are monotonous, emphasizing the mechanization of clerical work.
- Bartleby’s passive resistance symbolizes a rejection of this dehumanization.
2. The Nature of Resistance and Nonconformity
Bartleby’s famous refrain, “I would prefer not to,” embodies passive resistance. Unlike active rebellion, Bartleby’s refusal is subtle yet profound, challenging authority and societal expectations.
Discussion points:
- The difference between passive and active resistance.
- Bartleby as a symbol of individual nonconformity.
- Society’s inability to handle nonconformity constructively.
3. Isolation and Alienation
Throughout the story, Bartleby’s aloofness and withdrawal reflect deep-seated feelings of alienation. His indifferent attitude and eventual death in prison symbolize the tragic consequences of societal neglect.
Themes explored:
- The loneliness inherent in modern life.
- The failure of empathy in social institutions.
- The tragic consequences of misunderstood or ignored individual suffering.
4. Morality and Compassion
The lawyer’s moral dilemma centers around his conflicting impulses—his desire to help Bartleby versus his need to maintain his business. The story questions whether true compassion can exist within a capitalist framework.
Points of reflection:
- The limitations of charity and benevolence.
- The moral responsibilities of society towards marginalized individuals.
- The irony of the lawyer’s attempts to help Bartleby ultimately failing.
---
Symbolism in "Bartleby, the Scrivener"
1. Bartleby’s Refrain: “I would prefer not to”
This phrase encapsulates passive resistance and the refusal to comply with societal expectations. It symbolizes individual autonomy and the limits of authority.
2. The Office Environment
The office is a microcosm of the larger capitalist system — organized, efficient, yet emotionally cold. It reflects the mechanization of labor and the suppression of individuality.
3. The Dead Letter Office
Bartleby’s death in the prison’s dead letter office signifies the neglect of human needs and the failure of societal institutions to respond to personal tragedy.
---
Interpretations and Critical Perspectives
1. A Reflection of Melville’s Personal Struggles
Some scholars interpret “Bartleby” as a reflection of Melville’s own feelings of alienation and frustration with the societal changes of his time. The story mirrors the artist’s struggle to find meaning amidst a rapidly industrializing world.
2. An Allegory of the Human Condition
Many interpret Bartleby as an allegory for existential despair. His passive resistance becomes a metaphor for the human tendency to withdraw in the face of an incomprehensible or indifferent universe.
3. A Critique of Capitalism
The story critiques the dehumanizing effects of capitalism, emphasizing how the system reduces individuals to mere functions and suppresses authentic human expression.
4. Psychological and Philosophical Readings
- Existentialism: Bartleby’s refusal to participate reflects existential themes of choice, absurdity, and alienation.
- Psychoanalysis: His behavior can be seen as a manifestation of repressed trauma or mental illness.
---
Enduring Significance of "Bartleby, the Scrivener"
1. Influence on Literature and Culture
Melville’s story has influenced countless writers and thinkers, inspiring discussions on nonconformity, resistance, and the human spirit.
Notable references include:
- The term “Bartleby” as a symbol of passive resistance.
- Its influence on modernist and existentialist literature.
2. Relevance in Contemporary Society
Today, “Bartleby” resonates in discussions about workplace alienation, mental health, and societal indifference. The story prompts reflection on how modern institutions can neglect individual well-being.
3. Educational and Philosophical Value
The story serves as a valuable pedagogical tool for exploring complex themes related to ethics, psychology, and social responsibility.
---
Conclusion
Herman Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” remains a profound exploration of individuality, resistance, and societal dehumanization. Through the enigmatic figure of Bartleby, the story raises enduring questions about the nature of work, compassion, and the human capacity for passive defiance. Its rich symbolism and thematic depth continue to inspire readers and scholars alike, making it a cornerstone of American literary heritage. As society grapples with issues of alienation and the moral obligations toward marginalized individuals, Melville’s story offers timeless insights into the complexities of human existence and the silent struggles that often go unnoticed beneath the surface of everyday life.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the central theme of Melville's 'Bartleby, the Scrivener'?
The story explores themes of alienation, the dehumanizing effects of capitalism, and the limits of individual agency within a bureaucratic system.
Who is Bartleby, and what is his significance in the story?
Bartleby is a passive, enigmatic scrivener who gradually withdraws from society and work, symbolizing the struggle against societal indifference and the dehumanization of workers.
How does Melville portray the narrator in 'Bartleby, the Scrivener'?
The narrator is a compassionate but passive lawyer who is baffled by Bartleby's behavior, highlighting themes of empathy, helplessness, and societal complicity.
What is the role of the setting in 'Bartleby, the Scrivener'?
The story is set in a small, cramped office in New York City, which emphasizes the oppressive, monotonous environment that reflects the themes of alienation and dehumanization.
Why is Bartleby’s famous phrase 'I would prefer not to' significant?
It exemplifies Bartleby's passive resistance and refusal to conform, symbolizing individual autonomy and quiet rebellion against authority.
How has 'Bartleby, the Scrivener' influenced modern discussions on workplace and mental health issues?
The story is often referenced in discussions about workplace alienation, depression, and the mental health struggles of employees in monotonous or oppressive environments.
What are some modern interpretations of Melville’s 'Bartleby, the Scrivener'?
Modern interpretations view the story as a critique of capitalism, a meditation on existential despair, or an exploration of passive resistance and individualism in contemporary society.
