In John Green’s bestselling novel The Fault in Our Stars, Augustus Waters stands out as a charismatic and profound character whose life and philosophy significantly influence the story's emotional depth. While the novel explores themes of love, mortality, and the human condition, one recurring topic that sparks much debate among readers and critics alike is the so-called "fault" associated with Augustus Waters. This notion of fault is intertwined with his personality, choices, and perhaps even his destiny, making it a compelling aspect to analyze. This article delves into the concept of Augustus Waters' fault in The Fault in Our Stars, examining its origins, implications, and the broader philosophical questions it raises.
---
Understanding the Character of Augustus Waters
Who Is Augustus Waters?
Augustus Waters is introduced as a charismatic, confident, and witty teenager suffering from osteosarcoma, a type of bone cancer. His character embodies a blend of optimism, intelligence, and a certain rebellious streak. He is known for his charm, sense of humor, and philosophical outlook on life and death. His relationship with Hazel Grace Lancaster, the novel’s protagonist, forms the emotional core of the story, highlighting themes of love and mortality.
Augustus’ Philosophy and worldview
Augustus is a character who believes in making a mark on the world, often summarized by his famous assertion: "I want to go out with a bang." His worldview is characterized by a desire to seek meaning and significance despite the inevitability of death. This outlook influences his actions and decisions throughout the novel, often reflecting a complex interplay between hope and despair.
---
The Concept of Fault in the Novel
What Does “Fault” Refer To?
The phrase "fault" in the context of the novel is most famously associated with a line Hazel hears from her favorite author, Peter Van Houten: “Some infinities are bigger than other infinities.” The novel plays on the idea that everyone has a "fault," a flaw or imperfection that defines them. For Augustus, this concept is often linked to his own personality traits, choices, or perhaps his fate.
The Fault in Our Stars: A Literary and Philosophical Device
The phrase “fault in our stars” is a poetic twist on William Shakespeare’s Hamlet, which speaks of "the fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars." Green creatively repurposes this to suggest that faults—whether personal or cosmic—shape human destiny. For Augustus, this idea prompts reflection on whether his own flaws or "faults" contributed to his journey and ultimate demise.
---
Analyzing Augustus Waters’ Fault
Personal Flaws and Character Traits
While Augustus is often portrayed as charming and courageous, he is not without flaws. Some aspects that could be considered his "faults" include:
- Overconfidence: His belief that he can control or influence his fate and the world around him.
- Idealism: His pursuit of a heroic legacy sometimes blinds him to real-world limitations.
- Impulsiveness: His quick decisions and emotional responses, especially regarding love and mortality.
- Possessiveness: His intense feelings for Hazel sometimes lead to feelings of insecurity or jealousy.
These traits, while human and relatable, also serve as potential sources of conflict or tragedy, contributing to the novel’s exploration of human imperfection.
His Choices and Their Consequences
Augustus makes several pivotal choices that could be interpreted as faults:
- His obsession with fulfilling his "wish" to meet Peter Van Houten: Driven by idealism, this pursuit leads to disappointment.
- His decision to keep Hazel at arm’s length emotionally: Despite his feelings, he sometimes struggles with vulnerability.
- His handling of his cancer prognosis: His bravado masks underlying fears, influencing how he confronts his mortality.
These decisions demonstrate the complex interplay between his personality traits and the circumstances he faces, illustrating how personal faults can shape life paths.
Is Augustus’s Fault a Moral or Existential One?
Some readers interpret Augustus’s fault as a moral failing, such as arrogance or selfishness. Others see it as an existential flaw—his human limitations and the tragic inevitability of his fate. The novel suggests that the fault may be in the stars, or perhaps within human nature itself, emphasizing the universality of imperfection.
---
The Significance of Augustus Waters’ Fault in the Narrative
Driving the Plot
Augustus’s faults and decisions propel much of the story’s emotional tension. His pursuit of meaning, love, and legacy often lead to moments of hope and despair, shaping Hazel’s journey as well. His flaws highlight the fragility of life and the importance of embracing imperfection.
Creating Emotional Depth
By showcasing Augustus’s faults, Green provides a realistic and relatable portrayal of adolescence and mortality. His imperfections make him human, allowing readers to connect deeply with his struggles and triumphs.
Philosophical Reflection
The concept of fault invites reflection on human nature and destiny. It raises questions such as:
- Are our faults predetermined or shaped by circumstances?
- Can acknowledging faults lead to personal growth?
- Is the "fault" in our stars, or in ourselves?
Augustus’s character embodies these philosophical inquiries, enriching the novel’s thematic layers.
---
Conclusion: The Legacy of Augustus Waters’ Fault
The idea of fault in The Fault in Our Stars is a nuanced and layered concept. Augustus Waters, with his charismatic personality and tragic fate, exemplifies how personal flaws and choices intersect with the broader forces of destiny. His faults—whether in his confidence, idealism, or impulsiveness—serve as essential elements that define his character and drive the narrative forward. Ultimately, Augustus’s story reminds us that human imperfection is universal and that embracing our faults—while striving for meaning—may be the truest form of heroism. His legacy endures not only through the poignant love story but also through the profound philosophical questions about the nature of fault, fate, and the human condition.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Augustus Waters' main fault in 'The Fault in Our Stars'?
Augustus Waters' main fault is his tendency to idealize his relationships and sometimes prioritize his own desires over others', which leads to moments of selfishness and emotional complexity in the story.
How does Augustus Waters' fault affect his relationship with Hazel in 'The Fault in Our Stars'?
His fault for idealizing their relationship can cause misunderstandings and moments of emotional distance, but ultimately, his honesty and vulnerability help deepen their connection.
Is Augustus Waters' fault portrayed as a major flaw in his character? Why or why not?
While Augustus has flaws, such as his tendency to romanticize life and sometimes act impulsively, these are portrayed as human imperfections rather than major character flaws, making him a relatable and sympathetic character.
What lesson can be learned from Augustus Waters' fault in the novel?
The novel teaches that acknowledging our faults and imperfections is part of being human, and that genuine relationships involve understanding and accepting each other's flaws.
Does Augustus Waters' fault impact the story's overall message in 'The Fault in Our Stars'?
Yes, his faults highlight the themes of vulnerability, love, and mortality, emphasizing that even imperfect individuals can find meaning and connection amidst life's hardships.
