William Butler Yeats's poem The Second Coming is widely regarded as one of the most powerful and enigmatic works of 20th-century poetry. Its vivid imagery, complex symbolism, and apocalyptic tone have intrigued readers and scholars alike since its publication in 1920. The phrase “the second coming” itself holds profound religious and cultural connotations, referencing the anticipated return of Christ in Christian theology, but Yeats’s depiction extends beyond traditional religious frameworks to evoke a broader sense of chaos, transformation, and upheaval. In this analysis, we will explore the themes, imagery, symbolism, and stylistic devices that underpin the poem, providing insight into its enduring significance.
---
Context and Background
Historical and Personal Context
Yeats wrote The Second Coming in the aftermath of World War I, a period marked by unprecedented violence, political upheaval, and societal disillusionment. The war's devastation shattered the certainties of Western civilization, prompting many contemporaries to question progress and stability. Yeats, deeply influenced by the tumult of the early 20th century, saw the world teetering on the brink of chaos, which is reflected in the poem’s apocalyptic tone.
Yeats's personal engagement with mysticism and the occult also informs the poem. He was interested in esoteric philosophies and believed in cyclical histories—ideas that suggest civilizations rise and fall in recurring patterns. The Second Coming encapsulates these ideas, portraying history as a spiraling process culminating in a new, often unsettling, era.
Literary Context
Published in 1920, the poem is part of the modernist movement, characterized by its break from traditional forms, experimentation with language, and focus on fragmented realities. Yeats employs symbolism, allusion, and unconventional rhythms to evoke the disorientation of the modern world. The poem’s apocalyptic imagery resonates with other modernist works that grapple with chaos, alienation, and the breakdown of societal norms.
---
Structural and Formal Analysis
Form and Rhyme Scheme
The Second Coming is composed of two stanzas—one of twelve lines and the other of six—making a total of eighteen lines, which aligns with the symbolic significance of the number. The poem does not follow a strict rhyme scheme but employs a loose, irregular pattern that emphasizes its chaotic themes. The use of free verse and irregular meter reflects the disorder Yeats perceives in the world.
The poem’s rhythm is uneven, with lines varying in length and stress, creating a sense of instability. This stylistic choice immerses the reader in the tumult of the speaker’s vision.
Imagery and Symbolism
Yeats employs stark, often unsettling imagery to depict a world in upheaval. The opening lines set the tone with references to a “rough beast” slouching towards Bethlehem, symbolizing impending chaos or destruction. The imagery is both vivid and symbolic, layered with multiple meanings that invite interpretation.
---
Thematic Analysis
Chaos and Disorder
At its core, The Second Coming depicts a world plunged into chaos. The lines “Turning and turning in the widening gyre” suggest spiraling movement, symbolizing societal disintegration and the breakdown of order. The gyre, a recurring motif in Yeats’s work, represents cyclical history—each cycle ending in chaos before a new order emerges.
The “blood-dimmed tide” and “things fall apart” evoke a sense of violence and disintegration, reflecting the turbulent post-war environment. The chaos is not contained but expanding, making the future unpredictable and ominous.
Transformation and Rebirth
While the poem portrays chaos, it also hints at transformation. The phrase “the second coming” alludes to a rebirth or a new era, but Yeats’s depiction complicates traditional religious expectations. Instead of a peaceful return of Christ, the poem suggests that a monstrous force is emerging, embodying the primal and destructive aspects of change.
The line “And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, / Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?” implies that the new era may be born from chaos, possibly bringing destruction rather than salvation.
Religious and Mystical Allusions
Yeats’s imagery is heavily laden with religious symbolism. Bethlehem, the birthplace of Christ, becomes a site of ominous birth rather than salvation. The “rough beast” could symbolize a new, perhaps antithetical, messianic figure—one that embodies chaos instead of peace.
The poem also references the “widening gyre,” a concept from Yeats’s esoteric philosophy, representing the cyclical nature of history and spiritual evolution. The idea is that history moves in repeating spirals, with each cycle ending in chaos before renewal.
---
Stylistic Devices and Language
Imagery and Metaphor
Yeats’s use of vivid imagery—such as “blood-dimmed tide” and “the darkness drops again”—creates an apocalyptic mood. The “rough beast” serves as a powerful metaphor for an emerging force that signifies destruction but also potential rebirth.
Allusion and Symbolism
The poem alludes to religious texts, mystical concepts, and historical cycles. The allusion to Bethlehem anchors the poem in Christian symbolism, while the gyre symbolizes spiritual and historical cycles.
Sound and Rhythm
Although the poem lacks a strict rhyme scheme, Yeats employs alliteration (“turning and turning,” “blood-dimmed”) and consonance to create a rhythmic tension. The irregular meter enhances the sense of instability and chaos.
Language and Tone
The diction is stark, intense, and evocative. Words like “blood,” “darkness,” “chaos,” and “rough beast” evoke a sense of dread. The tone is prophetic, ominous, and reflecting Yeats’s concern about the future.
---
Interpretations and Criticisms
Multiple Readings
The Second Coming lends itself to multiple interpretations. Some view it as a commentary on the political upheavals of Yeats’s time, such as the Russian Revolution and the collapse of empires. Others see it as a reflection on the spiritual crisis and the decline of Christian civilization.
Philosophically, the poem can be read as an exploration of cyclical history—each cycle ending in destruction before renewal—suggesting that chaos is inherent in the process of change.
Criticisms and Controversies
Some critics argue that the poem’s apocalyptic tone is overly pessimistic or deterministic. Others interpret the “rough beast” as a symbol of modern technological or industrial forces that threaten human values.
Nevertheless, the poem’s ambiguity and layered symbolism have contributed to its enduring fascination.
---
Conclusion
The Second Coming stands as a profound meditation on the chaos and complexity of modern history and spiritual renewal. Yeats’s masterful use of imagery, symbolism, and language captures a world on the brink of transformation—one that is both terrifying and potentially rebirthful. Its themes resonate across generations, reflecting universal concerns about societal upheaval, spiritual decline, and the inevitable cycles of history. As a work of modernist poetry, it challenges readers to confront the chaos within and around them, encouraging reflection on the forces that shape human destiny.
The poem remains a powerful reminder of the unpredictable nature of change and the enduring human quest for meaning amid chaos. Whether viewed through a religious lens, a political perspective, or a spiritual one, The Second Coming continues to evoke a sense of awe and contemplation, cementing its place as a cornerstone of modern poetic achievement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main themes explored in 'The Second Coming' poetry?
The poem explores themes of chaos, societal collapse, the loss of innocence, and the arrival of a new, often unsettling, era symbolized by the second coming of a figure or event.
How does William Butler Yeats use imagery to convey the mood in 'The Second Coming'?
Yeats employs vivid and apocalyptic imagery such as 'blood-dimmed tide' and 'rough beast' to evoke a sense of disorder, foreboding, and transformation, enhancing the poem's ominous tone.
What is the significance of the falcon and the falconer in the poem?
The falcon and falconer symbolize the breakdown of societal order and the loss of control, illustrating how modern civilization is spiraling away from stability and rationality.
How does Yeats's use of symbolism in 'The Second Coming' reflect his political and cultural concerns?
Yeats uses symbols like the 'widening gyre' and the 'rough beast' to reflect his fears about political upheaval, the decline of Western civilization, and the impending chaos that could lead to a new era.
In what ways does 'The Second Coming' reflect Yeats's personal beliefs and mysticism?
The poem incorporates Yeats's interest in mysticism, suggesting a spiritual or mystical cycle of destruction and rebirth, and referencing esoteric symbols that imply a larger cosmic order.
What is the critical interpretation of the ending lines of 'The Second Coming'?
The ending lines depict a 'rough beast' slouching towards Bethlehem, symbolizing an ominous new era that is both inevitable and threatening, prompting reflection on the cyclical nature of history and the potential for chaos before renewal.
