Topdog/Underdog is a compelling play written by Suzan-Lori Parks that explores themes of identity, competition, race, and family dynamics through the intense relationship between two African American brothers. The play, which premiered in 2001 and won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 2002, is renowned for its powerful dialogue, complex characters, and layered storytelling. At its core, Topdog/Underdog presents a nuanced exploration of sibling rivalry, dreams deferred, and the quest for self-acceptance within the context of a fractured family history.
---
Introduction to the Play
Topdog/Underdog centers around two brothers, Lincoln and Booth, who inhabit a shared space fraught with tension, rivalry, and unspoken history. The title itself is symbolic, drawing from the names of U.S. Presidents Abraham Lincoln (Topdog) and John Wilkes Booth (Underdog), hinting at themes of power, betrayal, and identity. Parks uses these monikers to reflect the roles the brothers play in each other’s lives and to underscore the constant struggle for dominance and recognition.
The play is set in a single apartment in an unnamed city, where the brothers’ interactions reveal a complex history of familial bonds strained by economic hardship and personal disappointment. Parks’ use of sharp, poetic dialogue and minimalist staging emphasizes the intimacy and intensity of the characters’ psychological battles.
---
Characters and Their Dynamics
Lincoln
- The older brother, who assumes the role of the "Topdog" in the family hierarchy.
- A former street performer who used to do card tricks and impersonations.
- Struggles with his sense of identity, self-worth, and the legacy of his family’s history.
- Works as a day laborer and is haunted by his past choices and present frustrations.
Booth
- The younger brother, living in the shadow of Lincoln’s past.
- Has recently been released from jail, seeking stability and respect.
- Aspires to reinvent himself, often idealizing the life of a con artist or a "player."
- Is impulsive, ambitious, but also vulnerable and seeking approval from Lincoln.
Other Characters
- The play primarily focuses on Lincoln and Booth, but minor characters or references include the brothers’ late father and their shared history.
Family history and the rivalry between Lincoln and Booth underpin every interaction, revealing deep-seated feelings of jealousy, inadequacy, and longing for recognition.
---
Plot Summary
Opening Scene
The play begins with Lincoln teaching Booth how to play three-card monte, a street con game. Lincoln, who once performed as a card trick artist, now teaches his brother how to deceive others for money. Their interactions are laced with sarcasm, humor, and underlying tension. Lincoln’s authoritative demeanor contrasts with Booth’s rebellious attitude, setting the tone for their ongoing power struggle.
Rekindling and Conflict
As the play unfolds, Booth expresses a desire to leave their shared environment and start anew, possibly moving to Las Vegas or pursuing a career as a performer himself. Lincoln, however, is resistant, feeling trapped by his past and current circumstances. The brothers’ conversations reveal their shared history of hardship, including their father's abandonment and their own struggles with crime and survival.
A significant turning point occurs when Lincoln reveals that he has been practicing a new act — impersonating Abraham Lincoln — which he plans to perform at a local nightclub. This act symbolizes his attempt to reclaim a sense of dignity and identity beyond his current life.
Climactic Confrontation
Tensions escalate when Booth attempts to assert dominance, challenging Lincoln’s authority and teasing him about his insecurities. Booth’s impulsiveness leads to a heated argument, during which Booth finally confesses his deep-seated resentment and desire to carve his own path, separate from Lincoln.
In a moment of vulnerability, Lincoln confesses feelings of inadequacy and fear of being overshadowed. The brothers' rivalry becomes physical, culminating in Booth firing a gun at Lincoln — a symbolic moment representing the destructive nature of their competition and unresolved anger.
Resolution and Reflection
The play concludes with Lincoln wounded but alive, and Booth contemplating his future. The ending leaves audiences questioning whether the cycle of rivalry and familial loyalty can be broken or if it will perpetuate across generations.
Throughout the play, Parks masterfully explores the tension between individual aspirations and familial bonds, illustrating how personal dreams can be both a source of motivation and conflict.
---
Thematic Elements of the Plot
Identity and Performance
The play examines how characters perform roles to navigate societal expectations and personal insecurities. Lincoln’s impersonation of Abraham Lincoln is both a literal act and a metaphor for the masks people wear in everyday life.
Racial and Social Class Struggles
By setting the story in an urban environment and referencing historical figures, Parks highlights ongoing issues of racial identity, economic hardship, and societal marginalization faced by African Americans.
Sibling Rivalry and Family Loyalty
The intense competition and underlying affection between Lincoln and Booth reflect the universal struggles of sibling rivalry, compounded by external pressures and internal family dynamics.
Power and Control
The play scrutinizes how characters seek power and control within their relationships, often through deception, bravado, or violence. The constant shifting of dominance between Lincoln and Booth underscores the fragile nature of their relationship.
---
Symbolism and Significance of the Title
The title Topdog/Underdog encapsulates the core of the play’s conflict:
- Topdog symbolizes dominance, authority, and aspiration for respect.
- Underdog signifies vulnerability, suppression, and the desire to rise above adversity.
This dichotomy manifests in the brothers’ roles, their aspirations, and their self-perceptions. The play suggests that these roles are fluid and often self-imposed, with characters oscillating between strength and subjugation.
---
Critical Reception and Impact
Topdog/Underdog received widespread critical acclaim for its incisive portrayal of complex characters and its profound exploration of race, family, and identity. Critics praised Parks’ sharp dialogue, minimalist staging, and the play’s emotional depth. Its success not only earned it the Pulitzer Prize but also positioned Parks as a significant voice in contemporary American theater.
The play’s themes resonate with audiences because they touch on universal human experiences—struggle, ambition, betrayal, and reconciliation—set against the specific context of African American life and history.
---
Conclusion
Topdog/Underdog is a masterful exploration of familial relationships, identity, and societal roles. Through the intense and often raw interactions between Lincoln and Booth, Parks reveals the complexities of human nature and the enduring impact of family history. The play’s rich symbolism, compelling characters, and thought-provoking themes make it a landmark work in American theater.
Its plot, centered around rivalry and reconciliation, underscores the idea that the lines between dominance and submission are often blurred, and that personal and collective histories shape our present identities. Ultimately, Topdog/Underdog challenges audiences to reflect on the masks they wear and the battles they fight within their own lives, making it a timeless and powerful piece of dramatic literature.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main plot of 'Topdog/Underdog'?
'Topdog/Underdog' is a play that centers around two brothers, Lincoln and Booth, who navigate their complex relationship filled with rivalry, identity struggles, and past grievances, set against the backdrop of their lives in New York City.
Who are the main characters in 'Topdog/Underdog'?
The main characters are Lincoln, who takes on the persona of a famous African American gambler, and his younger brother Booth, who aspires to be a convincing con artist, both grappling with their shared history and personal aspirations.
What are the central themes of 'Topdog/Underdog'?
The play explores themes such as brotherhood and rivalry, identity and self-perception, racial and societal struggles, and the complex dynamics of family relationships.
How does the relationship between Lincoln and Booth develop in the play?
Their relationship is marked by tension, competition, and moments of vulnerability, revealing deep-seated insecurities and a desire for connection, which ultimately leads to both conflict and understanding.
What is the significance of the title 'Topdog/Underdog'?
The title reflects the power dynamics between the brothers, with 'Topdog' representing dominance and control, and 'Underdog' symbolizing vulnerability and subversion, highlighting the play's exploration of identity and societal roles.
Is 'Topdog/Underdog' based on real events or characters?
No, 'Topdog/Underdog' is a work of fiction by Suzan-Lori Parks, inspired by themes of race, family, and identity, rather than real events or individuals.
