In Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan, Chapter 13, titled "Of the Natural Condition of Mankind, as Concerning Their Felicity and Misery," Hobbes explores the fundamental state of human existence prior to societal organization. This chapter provides a critical foundation for understanding Hobbes's political philosophy by examining the natural condition of mankind—what life is like without government, laws, or social contracts. The chapter delves into human nature, the inherent conflicts, and the reasons that necessitate the establishment of a sovereign authority to maintain peace and prevent chaos. A thorough grasp of this chapter is essential for appreciating Hobbes's argument for the necessity of a powerful sovereign and the social contract.
---
Introduction to Human Nature in the State of Nature
Hobbes begins by describing the natural condition of mankind, which he refers to as the "state of nature." This is a hypothetical scenario where no civil society, government, or authority exists to regulate human behavior. According to Hobbes, understanding this condition is vital because it reveals why humans have historically sought to establish political order.
The State of Nature Defined
Hobbes characterizes the state of nature as a state of perpetual war of "every man against every man." In this condition:
- There are no laws or authority to restrain individuals.
- Humans are driven primarily by natural passions, especially the desire for self-preservation.
- There is a constant threat of violence and insecurity.
He emphasizes that, in this state, there are no distinctions of property or rights, as everything is in a state of chaos and conflict.
The Equality of Humans
Despite differences in physical strength, Hobbes asserts that humans are essentially equal in their natural faculties and abilities to harm or be harmed. This equality breeds competition, mistrust, and fear, as no one is secure from the violence of others.
---
The Natural Condition of Humanity
Hobbes's analysis of human nature in the state of nature reveals several core aspects:
Desire for Self-Preservation
- Every individual naturally seeks to survive and preserve their life.
- This desire is the primary motivator of human actions.
- It often leads to conflicts, as individuals pursue their interests without regard for others.
Competition, Diffidence, and Glory
Hobbes describes three principal causes that lead humans into conflict:
1. Competition: People seek to acquire resources and possessions, leading to conflict over these goods.
2. Diffidence: Fear of others causes individuals to preemptively attack to ensure their safety.
3. Glory: The desire for reputation, honor, and recognition can motivate aggressive behaviors.
The Lack of Justice and Morality
In the state of nature, there are no established laws or moral principles. Justice, as a social construct, does not exist outside civil society. Consequently:
- Rights are not formally defined; individuals can do anything to preserve themselves.
- There's no obligation to keep promises or respect others' property.
- Morality is subjective and based on individual passions rather than universal standards.
---
The Conditions of Life in the State of Nature
Hobbes famously describes the life of humans in this natural state as "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." Several factors contribute to this bleak outlook:
The War of All Against All
- The natural condition is characterized by a state of constant conflict.
- Without a common authority, individuals are in a continuous state of war, where every person fights against every other.
- This war is not necessarily physical violence at all times but a state of insecurity and preparedness for violence.
The Lack of Security and Peace
- Due to mutual distrust, individuals cannot enjoy peace or stability.
- The fear of violent death or loss of possessions dominates human life.
- Every person is a threat to others, and vice versa.
The Insecurity of Property and Life
- In the absence of laws, there are no guarantees of property rights.
- Human life is precarious, as others may violently seize what they want.
- The natural condition thus fosters a constant state of danger.
---
The Natural Rights and Liberties of Humans
Hobbes emphasizes that in the state of nature, humans have an unlimited right to do anything necessary for their self-preservation. Key points include:
- Right to All Things: Every individual has the liberty to use their abilities to their advantage.
- No External Limitations: Without a higher authority, there are no restrictions on actions, including violence.
- Consequences of Unlimited Rights: This freedom leads to inevitable conflict, as others seek to do the same.
Hobbes warns that these natural rights, while essential for survival, also make life dangerous and unstable, reinforcing the need for some form of control.
---
The Transition from the State of Nature to Civil Society
Hobbes argues that because the natural condition is so perilous, humans have a natural inclination to seek peace and security, which leads to the formation of civil society through social contracts. The main reasons for this transition include:
- The desire to escape the chaos of the state of nature.
- The recognition that mutual cooperation provides greater safety.
- The understanding that individuals can better preserve themselves under a sovereign authority.
He emphasizes that this transition is voluntary, based on rational self-interest, and involves individuals ceding some of their natural rights to a sovereign in exchange for peace and security.
---
Implications for Political Philosophy
Hobbes's portrayal of the natural condition has several profound implications:
- It demonstrates that the state of nature is undesirable and unstable.
- It justifies the establishment of a sovereign with absolute authority to prevent the return to chaos.
- It underpins Hobbes's social contract theory, where individuals collectively agree to surrender certain rights for the collective good.
He contends that without such a sovereign, human life would be characterized by continual conflict, making civil society and progress impossible.
---
Summary of Key Points
- The natural condition of mankind is a state of war where every individual is against every other.
- Humans are naturally equal, driven by passions such as self-preservation, competition, fear, and glory.
- In this state, there are no laws, justice, or morality; individuals are free to do anything necessary for their survival.
- The life in the natural condition is insecure, unstable, and short.
- To escape this chaos, humans voluntarily relinquish certain rights through a social contract, creating a sovereign to maintain peace.
- The transition from the state of nature to civil society is necessary for the preservation of life and the development of civilization.
---
Conclusion
Thomas Hobbes's Chapter 13 of Leviathan provides a bleak but realistic portrayal of human life without societal constraints. By analyzing the natural condition of mankind, Hobbes underscores the necessity of a strong, central authority to prevent the destructive consequences of human passions unchecked. This chapter forms the foundation of Hobbes's argument that peace and order are best maintained through an absolute sovereign, which individuals willingly create to escape the natural state of war. Understanding this chapter is crucial for grasping Hobbes’s overall philosophy on the origins of society, the nature of human beings, and the justification for political authority.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main focus of Chapter 13 in Hobbes's Leviathan?
Chapter 13 discusses the natural condition of mankind, describing it as a state of war of every man against every man due to competition, diffidence, and glory.
How does Hobbes describe the state of nature in Chapter 13?
Hobbes portrays the state of nature as a condition of constant conflict, where life is 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short' because there is no authority to maintain peace.
What are the three principal causes of conflict identified by Hobbes in Chapter 13?
The three causes are competition (for resources), diffidence (fear of others), and glory (desire for reputation and honor).
According to Hobbes in Chapter 13, what is the natural condition of mankind without a common power?
Without a common power, mankind exists in a state of perpetual war, with no security or peace, where every individual acts according to their own interests.
How does Hobbes justify the need for a social contract in Chapter 13?
He argues that humans collectively agree to surrender some of their freedoms to a sovereign authority to escape the chaos and violence of the natural state.
What role does fear play in Hobbes's explanation of human behavior in Chapter 13?
Fear of violent death and insecurity drives individuals to seek peace through social contracts and the establishment of authority.
How does Chapter 13 of Leviathan contribute to Hobbes’s overall argument for an absolute sovereign?
It establishes that the natural condition is chaotic and dangerous, making a strong, centralized authority essential to ensure peace and safety for all.
