The thirteenth chapter of Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan serves as a crucial component in understanding Hobbes’ conception of the natural condition of mankind and the origins of human laws and societal structures. This chapter delves into the natural state of humans, their instincts, and how their inherent tendencies shape the necessity for social contracts and political authority. Hobbes' analysis in Chapter 13 provides the foundation for his argument that peace and order are only achievable through the establishment of a sovereign authority, which is justified by humans' natural inclinations toward self-preservation and competition.
---
Overview of Chapter 13
Chapter 13 is titled "Of the Natural Condition of Mankind." It explores what life is like before the formation of organized society and government. Hobbes posits that in the absence of political authority, humans exist in a state of nature characterized by chaos, conflict, and perpetual insecurity. This chapter lays the groundwork for understanding why humans cede their natural rights to a sovereign in exchange for peace and stability.
---
Natural State of Humanity
The State of Nature
Hobbes describes the natural condition of mankind as one of perpetual conflict and competition. In this state:
- There is no overarching authority or common power to enforce rules.
- Every individual has a natural right to do whatever they deem necessary to preserve themselves.
- Life is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short," emphasizing the brutality and instability of this condition.
Hobbes emphasizes that in this state, humans are driven by their natural passions—mainly:
- Desire for self-preservation
- Desire for power
- Fear of death and danger from others
Equality and Its Consequences
Despite differences in physical strength or intelligence, Hobbes argues that humans are fundamentally equal in their ability to threaten one another. This equality leads to:
- Competition, as individuals seek to secure resources and status
- Diffidence, or mutual suspicion, as everyone fears being harmed by others
- Glory, as individuals seek recognition and honor
These tendencies foster a constant state of conflict, as each person perceives others as threats or rivals.
---
The State of War
Hobbes asserts that the natural condition of mankind is a state of war—"every man against every man." Key points include:
- Insecurity: No one is safe, as others may attack to secure resources or power.
- Absence of Industry: Without peace, there is no room for arts, sciences, or economic development.
- Moral Relativism: In the state of nature, notions of right and wrong are meaningless because no authority enforces moral standards.
He stresses that this state of war is not necessarily constant fighting but a general condition of belligerence, where the potential for conflict is always present.
---
Natural Rights and Laws of Nature
Natural Rights
In the state of nature, humans possess the liberty to do whatever they believe necessary for their survival. Hobbes notes:
- Every individual has the right to use their own power as they see fit.
- There are no laws or norms regulating behavior.
Natural Laws
Despite the chaos, Hobbes introduces the concept of natural laws, which are:
- Precepts or general rules derived from human reason.
- Designed to promote self-preservation and peace.
The primary natural law, according to Hobbes, is:
- Seek peace and follow it.
- When peace is not possible, individuals may defend themselves by any means necessary.
He also discusses secondary laws, such as:
- Lay down your rights if others do the same, forming the basis for social contracts.
- Be willing to give up some freedoms to achieve peace and security.
---
The Need for a Social Contract
Hobbes underscores that humans, recognizing the destructive nature of the natural state, willingly surrender some of their rights and freedoms to a sovereign authority through a social contract. This is essential because:
- It establishes peace and security.
- It prevents the return to the state of war.
- It enables humans to pursue their interests more safely.
He emphasizes that this contract is a mutual agreement:
- All parties agree to relinquish their natural rights.
- They accept the authority of a sovereign who enforces laws and maintains order.
The legitimacy of the sovereign, Hobbes argues, comes from this voluntary agreement, not from divine right or tradition.
---
Implications of the Natural Condition
Hobbes’ depiction of the natural state has several significant implications:
- Human Nature: It reveals Hobbes’ view that humans are inherently self-interested and driven by passions.
- Necessity of Absolute Sovereignty: Given the chaos of the natural state, only an absolute sovereign can ensure peace.
- Foundation of Political Authority: The social contract forms the basis for legitimate political power.
He contends that without such an authority, society would revert to the natural state, which is incompatible with human progress and well-being.
---
Conclusion
Chapter 13 of Leviathan vividly portrays the natural condition of mankind as a state of war, driven by natural passions and the equality of humans in their capacity for conflict. Hobbes’ grim depiction underscores the necessity of a strong, centralized authority to escape this chaos. The chapter sets the stage for the subsequent discussion on the formation and nature of the sovereign power, which Hobbes sees as essential for civil society to flourish. It reflects Hobbes’ fundamental belief that peace and order are not natural states but achieved through deliberate social agreements that limit individual freedoms in favor of collective security. This understanding remains influential in political philosophy, emphasizing the importance of authority, law, and social cohesion in human societies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main focus of Chapter 13 in Leviathan?
Chapter 13 centers on the nature of the commonwealth’s power and the importance of a strong, absolute sovereign to maintain peace and order within the society.
How does Hobbes describe the sovereign's authority in Chapter 13?
Hobbes emphasizes that the sovereign's authority is absolute and undivided, necessary to prevent chaos and ensure societal stability.
What analogy does Hobbes use to explain the power of the sovereign in Chapter 13?
Hobbes compares the sovereign’s power to that of a father over his children, highlighting the need for unquestioned authority to maintain order.
Why is the sovereign's role considered crucial according to Chapter 13?
Because the sovereign’s role is to prevent civil war and disorder by holding the collective power of the commonwealth, ensuring peace and security.
How does Chapter 13 relate to Hobbes's concept of the social contract?
It reinforces the idea that individuals cede their natural rights to a sovereign through the social contract to achieve collective security and peace.
What are the potential dangers of weakening the sovereign’s power as discussed in Chapter 13?
Weakening the sovereign’s power could lead to civil unrest, conflict, and the collapse of social order, as there would be no authority to enforce laws.
