Chapter 17 of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein marks a pivotal turning point in the novel, as it captures the creature's first act of compassion and his attempt to seek a new beginning through his own moral agency. This chapter delves deep into the creature’s complex psyche, revealing his desire for companionship, understanding, and a sense of belonging. It is in this chapter that the creature begins to articulate his feelings, hopes, and the moral dilemmas that haunt him, setting the stage for the subsequent developments in the story.
---
Introduction to the Creature’s Request
In Chapter 17, after years of suffering and rejection, the creature finally confronts Frankenstein directly, demanding that Victor create a female companion for him. This moment signifies the creature's shift from a passive being to an active agent seeking justice and happiness. His plea is driven by his loneliness, the cruelty he endures from humans, and his hope for companionship that might alleviate his misery.
The creature begins by recounting his own miserable existence, emphasizing his suffering and the profound loneliness that has plagued him since his awakening. He describes how his initial innocence was corrupted by the cruelty of humans, and how he has been forced to live in isolation. This detailed account aims to evoke sympathy in Victor and persuade him of the moral imperative to create a partner for the creature.
---
The Creature’s Moral and Emotional Appeal
Expression of Sympathy and Humanity
The creature, despite being a monster by societal standards, reveals a deeply human side in Chapter 17. He acknowledges his own feelings and desires, emphasizing that he is capable of moral judgment and that his actions are driven by profound loneliness rather than inherent evil. His plea underscores the paradox of his existence: he is a being capable of both great harm and deep affection.
He explains to Victor that he is not inherently malicious but was made monstrous by the rejection and cruelty he faced. The creature insists that he seeks only companionship and understanding, and that his suffering is as intense as any human’s. This appeal is designed to appeal to Victor’s sense of morality, urging him to consider the creature’s plight and the consequences of creating or refusing to create a mate.
Request for a Female Companion
The core of the creature’s plea is his request for Victor to create a female companion. He argues that, having been abandoned by humanity, his only solace lies in companionship, and that without it, he is doomed to perpetuate misery and violence. The creature promises that if Victor creates a female, he will retire into the wilderness with her and live in seclusion, away from human society.
He emphasizes that his demand is not born out of malice but from a desire for peace and the avoidance of further suffering. The creature states that he believes his loneliness is a fundamental flaw in his existence and that a female companion could help restore some balance and morality to his life.
---
Victor’s Internal Conflict and Moral Dilemma
Victor’s Initial Rejection and Hesitation
Upon hearing the creature’s request, Victor is initially overwhelmed by conflicting emotions. He recognizes the moral weight of creating a new life form and fears the potential consequences. Victor’s internal conflict revolves around his responsibility as a scientist and his fear of unleashing a new, possibly more dangerous creature into the world.
He is also haunted by his previous mistakes—his hubris in creating the first creature and the subsequent chaos it caused. Victor’s conscience is troubled by the ethical implications of creating another being, especially one that could potentially threaten humanity. His hesitation reflects the broader themes of scientific responsibility and the ethical limits of human knowledge.
The Fear of Creating a Monster
Victor’s greatest concern is the possibility that the female creature might not be compliant or might refuse to live peacefully with her mate, resulting in a new breed of monsters that could threaten society. He fears that his actions could spiral into an uncontrollable chain of events, leading to further destruction and loss of life.
He is also worried about the potential suffering of the female creature, should she be created and then abandoned or mistreated. These fears lead him to consider the moral and practical consequences of his decision, weighing the desire to alleviate the creature’s suffering against the risk of unleashing new dangers.
Victor’s Decision to Delay
Ultimately, Victor is torn and decides to delay his decision. He promises to consider the creature’s request but is deeply conflicted about whether to proceed. This cautious approach underscores the novel’s exploration of moral ambiguity and the unpredictable consequences of scientific experimentation.
Victor’s reluctance also highlights his growing awareness of his own moral responsibility and foreshadows the tragic events that will follow. His delay signifies a critical turning point, where he begins to grapple more intensely with the ethical dilemmas of his actions.
---
The Creature’s Response and Reflection
The creature, sensing Victor’s hesitation, expresses a mixture of hope and despair. He reminds Victor of the importance of compassion and morality, implying that his existence hinges on the moral choices of humans. The creature’s plea is both a cry for understanding and a challenge to Victor’s conscience, urging him to do what is right despite the risks.
He articulates his own sense of justice, asserting that he has been wronged by society and that he only seeks companionship to find peace. The creature’s reflections expose the depth of his loneliness and his desire for connection, which he believes could be achieved through the creation of a female mate.
---
Significance of Chapter 17 in the Novel
Chapter 17 is a crucial component of Frankenstein because it encapsulates the central moral and philosophical questions that permeate the novel. The creature’s request introduces themes of morality, responsibility, and the unintended consequences of scientific hubris.
This chapter also deepens the reader’s understanding of the creature’s character, transforming him from a mere monster into a complex being capable of moral reasoning and emotional depth. His plea for a companion humanizes him and invites the reader to question the nature of monstrosity and the ethics of creation.
Furthermore, Victor’s internal conflict reflects the broader human struggle with moral responsibility and the limits of scientific inquiry. His hesitation foreshadows the tragic chain of events that will ensue and highlights the novel’s ongoing exploration of the consequences of overreach and neglect of moral duty.
---
Conclusion
In summary, Chapter 17 of Frankenstein is a profound exploration of morality, loneliness, and the consequences of scientific irresponsibility. The creature’s plea for a female companion marks a turning point in the narrative, emphasizing his human qualities and the ethical dilemmas faced by Victor Frankenstein. It raises essential questions about the responsibilities of creators toward their creations and the moral limits of scientific discovery.
This chapter not only advances the plot but also deepens the philosophical inquiry at the heart of the novel. It forces both Victor and the reader to confront uncomfortable truths about justice, compassion, and the nature of monstrosity. As the story progresses, the decisions made in Chapter 17 will have profound repercussions, underscoring the enduring relevance of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein as a cautionary tale about the perils of unchecked scientific ambition and the moral responsibilities inherent in creation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main focus of Chapter 17 in Frankenstein?
Chapter 17 centers on Victor Frankenstein's decision to create a female companion for the Creature, as he begins to understand the creature's loneliness and seeks to prevent further harm.
How does Victor Frankenstein justify his decision to create a female monster in Chapter 17?
Victor justifies his decision by recognizing the creature's loneliness and believing that providing a companion might mitigate its malicious tendencies, though he also fears the consequences of unleashing a new creature into the world.
What moral and ethical dilemmas are explored in Chapter 17 of Frankenstein?
Chapter 17 explores dilemmas surrounding scientific responsibility, the ethics of creating life, and the potential consequences of playing God, as Victor debates whether to proceed with creating the female creature.
How does Victor Frankenstein's relationship with the creature evolve in Chapter 17?
Initially, Victor feels a mix of obligation and dread about creating a companion for the creature, reflecting a complex relationship marked by guilt, fear, and a sense of responsibility.
What role does the theme of loneliness play in Chapter 17 of Frankenstein?
Loneliness is a central theme, highlighting the creature's desire for companionship and Victor's awareness of the consequences that creating a partner might have on both their lives.
What decision does Victor ultimately make at the end of Chapter 17?
Victor decides to abandon the plan to create a female companion for the creature, fearing the potential dangers and ethical implications, which leads to further conflict with the creature.
